The Tamil Nadu government on Tuesday told the Supreme Court that the 150-year-old tradition of lighting the Karthigai Deepam at Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai is associated with the Uchipillaiyar Temple's Deepathoon and not a disputed rock pillar near a dargah.Opposing a fresh demand to light the ceremonial lamp at the rock pillar, the state argued that there was no established custom or enforceable legal right to do so. The Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) department had rejected the request, citing the pillar's proximity to the dargah.During the hearing of appeals against a Madras High Court order, the court was told that the traditional location for lighting the lamp was a mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar Temple, also known as the Ganesh temple, situated on the hill.NO ESTABLISHED CUSTOM AT DISPUTED PILLAR: TNSenior advocate Gupta, appearing for the Tamil Nadu government, submitted that the 150-year-old practice of lighting the Deepam at the Uchipillaiyar Temple Deepathoon was an admitted position, recognised in earlier judicial pronouncements.

He argued that the petitioner seeking permission to light the lamp at another rock pillar had failed to establish any customary right to do so."If he claims that as a right, then he will have to demonstrate that there is such a practice in existence. Admittedly, there is no such custom.

There is no such established custom," Gupta told the bench. He also argued that the demand did not constitute a right enforceable through a writ of mandamus.The state cautioned that changing the existing arrangement could lead to a breach of peace, saying there had been unfortunate incidents involving both communities in the past.TN CITES 1923 DECREE, 1994 COURT ORDERThe government referred to a 1923 Privy Council decision on the ownership of Thiruparankundram hill.

It submitted that the temple owned the hill except Nellie Thoppu and the steps leading to the dargah, which were recognised as being under Muslim possession.Gupta also cited a 1994 court order, passed after Hindu Munnani announced plans to climb the hill and light the lamp at its summit. The temple authorities had maintained that the Deepam was traditionally lit at the mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar Temple.According to the state, the court had found that the petitioner had failed to establish any right to light the lamp at the hilltop.

It had directed that the Devasthanam alone would light the Deepam at the traditional location and that no other person would be permitted to do so.The government further said that the dargah's hakdars had secured decrees in 1862 and 1912 against attempts to light the lamp at the hilltop.The present dispute arose after the Madras High Court observed that the HR&CE department and the Devasthanam could consider permitting an applicant to light the Deepam at another location on the hill.The subsequent application was rejected after consultations with temple priests, police, fire officials and revenue authorities.TN SEEKS STATUS QUO PENDING FINAL DECISIONSenior advocate Shekhar Naphade, appearing for the state, argued that the hill's natural division into peaks and the proximity of the disputed pillar to the dargah had to be considered. He said allowing the ritual at the proposed location could affect public peace."The status quo was to light the lamp at the mandapam.

The status quo must be preserved," he submitted, seeking continuation of the existing arrangement until the court takes a final decision.Senior advocate Prashant Sen, appearing for the HR&CE department, said the decision on the location of the ritual rested with the Devasthanam and the department, in accordance with established Agama practices. He added that the petitioner had not demonstrated any violation of Agama Shastras or the temple management's legal duties.Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for the Madurai District Collector, also sought to make submissions.

He argued that the term 'Deepathoon' had appeared in the litigation for the first time in 2025.The Supreme Court said it would continue hearing the arguments on Wednesday at 2 pm.- Ends