New Delhi: The Supreme Court has refused to consolidate first information reports filed across states against an individual accused of participating in an investment fraud involving the sale of virtual cloud space. The bench observed that an accused person cannot dictate where victims lodge complaints and stated that overlapping investigations cannot be utilized to grant an advantage to the suspect.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana heard a petition submitted by Bhumi Uptalbhai Patel, who sought relief regarding criminal cases registered in both Gujarat and Haryana. While declining to combine the FIRs filed across the two states, the court noted that Patel remains free to approach the respective high courts to seek the consolidation of cases within each individual state.

During the proceedings, Justice Bagchi stated that an accused can neither choose the locations where victims register complaints nor prevent law enforcement agencies in different states from investigating alleged offenses within their respective jurisdictions. The court emphasized that it would not provide any advantage to an accused facing overlapping investigations, noting that handling such matters is up to the investigative agencies.

The bench asserted that the law must be applied in the strictest manner possible when dealing with organized cybercrime. Rejecting any requests for a lenient approach, Justice Bagchi maintained that the legal framework must be enforced at its harshest level without granting any leeway.

Criminal proceedings involving Patel are currently pending before trial courts located in Gandhinagar, Gujarat, and Faridabad, Haryana. Court records indicated that Patel had previously surrendered and that the relevant custody certificate had been submitted to the court.

As an undertrial prisoner, Patel had spent five months and five days in judicial custody while lodged at the Central Jail in Ahmedabad, Gujarat. Having declined to combine the separate criminal complaints registered in Gujarat and Haryana, the Supreme Court ultimately left the petitioner at liberty to pursue appropriate relief through the respective high courts.