An uncomfortable question has loomed over France ever since student protests against school conditions morphed into riots and looting led by masked perpetrators dressed in black: Who was behind them?In France, it is illegal for the state to collect statistics on race, ethnicity and religion.Far-right leader Marine Le Pen says the rioters came from neighborhoods with large immigrant populations. Far-left firebrand Jean-Luc Mélenchon says the real problem was law enforcement, accusing authorities of brutal and chaotic tactics that fueled the violence.
The French government, meanwhile, blames âultraleftâ agitators.Any attempt to get to the heart of the matter, however, immediately runs into a uniquely French form of resistance: a longstanding, deeply rooted practice of colorblindness.In France, it is illegal for the state to collect statistics on race, ethnicity and religion. That means law enforcement canât document whether French citizens detained in the rioting are descendants of immigrants or not.
Corporations, academics and others outside the state are also heavily restricted from gathering such data and are subject to five years in prison and a âŹ300,000 fine for breaking the rules. Itâs therefore hard to factor ethnicity or creed into public discussions of the riots because, in the eyes of the French state, these factors donât exist.To Americans, reared on multiculturalism, hyphenated identities and entrenched racial politics, it might seem impossible to not talk about race and cultural difference.
But in France, these concepts carry deep stigma, as they run counter to the countryâs founding principles.France considers its republic a model of Enlightenment universalism. What makes someone French isnât ethnicity but their allegiance to universalist valuesâliberty, the rule of law, democracy.
There is a French word for efforts to divide France along ethnic linesâcommunautarisme. And it is widely regarded as a precursor to ethno-religious separatism and even civil war.The recent unrest, however, shows that these fractures already exist, regardless of whether Franceâs colorblind republic sees them.
The protests began in the Paris banlieues, the poor outskirts where much of the countryâs Muslim population resides. The public school system there has for decades been a fulcrum of Franceâs struggle to assimilate immigrant communities.
Fights over Muslim headscarves and French secularism have spilled far beyond the classroom, dividing the countryâs electorate, often along cultural and ethnic lines.Polls show Le Pen and MĂ©lenchonâthe candidates who embody this partitionâare most likely to make the runoff in next springâs presidential election. Candidates in the center, drowned out by the turmoil, have seen support shrink.âThe politics of identity are replacing social classes in the language of political battles,â said Gilles Kepel, a prominent researcher who has studied the emergence of ethnic enclaves in France. âThose who ostensibly deplore these new fractures as abominable are in fact benefiting from them, if not outright causing them.âFranceâs universal republic, in other words, is producing the exact outcome it was designed to prevent.The French Revolution was fought to replace an order based on bloodlines with a national identity based on civic ideals of equality, freedom and brotherhood.To do that, revolutionary leaders aimed to overturn feudal structures and unite the mosaic of ethnicities and languages that shaped 18th century France.
More than 80% of its inhabitants at the time couldnât speak French fluently. Local vernaculars ranged from German to Gaelic, Basque, Occitan, Flemish, Yiddish, Walloon, Norman and countless shades of Patois.
Schools and the military were the universalist crucibles in which the new French citizens would be forged.As the industrial revolution brought an influx of Belgians, Italians, Swiss and Spaniards in the 19th century, France dropped all questions regarding religious beliefs or ethnic origin from its census and class became the main dividing line within French society.In letters they sent home toward the end of World War II, Black American soldiers stationed in liberated Europe wrote about the solace they found in colorblind France. They could enter cafes, hotels, theaters and restaurants without facing any restrictions.
Romantic relations between U.S. soldiers and locals seemed almost entirely free of any racial divides.To the French, however, the War was the ultimate cautionary tale of what could happen if the state abandoned universalism. When the Vichy regime adopted its first antisemitic laws in 1940, its government actually didnât know with certainty who fell under the statute.
Its solution was to force Jewish citizens to register with the policeâwhich almost 90% didâleading many to be deported to Nazi death camps.Vichy was a puppet fascist regime at odds with the traditions of the Republic. Postwar governments werenât free of contradictions either.
Franceâs colonial rule in North Africa also made a mockery of the universalist ideals as Algeriaâs Muslim population enjoyed limited political rights compared with native French settlers. Algeriaâs brutal war of independence brought a violent resolution to this contradiction in 1962âand ushered in a new wave of immigration.In the 1950s and 1960s, almost two million peopleâincluding Muslims, Christians and Sephardic Jewsâmoved from North Africa to France.
The newcomers joined and soon replaced blue-collar locals in the brutalist high-rise suburbsâthe banlieuesâthat fast-growing France was building to replace urban slums in Paris and other large cities.The lines of French society were being redrawn, yet the state remained officially unaware of the countryâs changing complexion. The shame of Jewish deportations had led postwar France to double down on the colorblind approach, passing a data protection act in 1978 that banned the collection and holding of records revealing racial origins or religious beliefs precisely because of the way it was weaponized.Into this information void stepped Jean-Marie Le Pen, who co-founded the far-right National Front with former SS Nazi members in 1972.
To him, being French was a matter of lineage. The Nazi gas chambers, he said, were âa point of detail in the history of the World War II.â Now, he said, France was being overrun by immigrants, particularly those from Franceâs former colonies in Africa.âThey will be in charge.
And the French will keep their heads down, get off the sidewalks and lower their eyes,â Le Pen told Le Monde in 2003, warning that 25 million Muslims would one day live in France. A year later Le Pen told a far-right publication that people were telling him: âMonsieur Le Pen, itâs already the case right now!âLe Pen had no data to back up his figures, but neither did his opponents in the political establishment to dispute him.
The government at the time relied on researchers who estimated Franceâs Muslim population was between four and five million. The estimates were largely based on the number of people who emigrated from Muslim majority countries and did not precisely account for their descendants.To many mainstream politicians, engaging in debate over cultural differencesâand whether such differences played a role in the socio-economic isolation of French Muslimsâsmacked of racism and validated Le Penâs rhetoric.
Le Pen was fined for his comments, which French courts ruled were forms of hate speech.âIt was impossible to talk about immigration, because the moment there was a problem, and we wanted to discuss it, someone would say: âBut you sound like Jean-Marie Le Pen. Youâre talking like National Front!â said Malika Sorel-Sutter, a French essayist of Algerian origins and a member of the European Parliament.The 21st century brought a wave of violence that placed new forms of pressure on Franceâs republican ideals.
The first major riots erupted in banlieues across the country in 2005 in response to the deaths of two teenagers who were electrocuted while hiding from police. The newsroom of satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo, which had published cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad, was the site of a massacre in 2015 by Al-Qaeda gunmen who were French citizens born of Algerian parents.
History teacher Samuel Paty was then beheaded by a Chechen refugee at his middle-school outside Paris in 2020 after he showed the Charlie Hebdo cartoons to his class as part of a lesson on free speech.Each crisis was greeted as a wake-up call that threatened the foundations of Franceâs universal model. But so were any attempts to understand their root causes.
A push by researchers to survey tens of thousands of people around the 2005 riots collided with the ban on collecting ethnic data. The French privacy watchdog, which vets scientific surveys before they are conducted, allowed the researchers to ask about religion, nationality and perceived discrimination but barred them from asking respondents to identify themselves by race, ethnicity or skin color.âIf thereâs discrimination in terms of income levels, to fight against it we have to know whoâs earning a lot and whoâs making less,â said Hugues Lagrange, a sociologist who took part in the study.President Emmanuel Macron proposed a law against âIslamist separatismâ in an effort to confront radical forms of Islam that his government said fueled the Charlie Hebdo and Paty killings.
But the country was immediately consumed by debates about what âIslamist separatismâ even meant. The government defined it as the dominance of religious rules over state authority in some Muslim communities, drafting legislation that aimed to tighten oversight of mosques and Muslim associations.
Opponents, including MĂ©lenchon, saw it as an attempt to stigmatize French Muslims as a group and as a violation of universal values. The law eventually passed, but without any mention of Islamist separatism.Over time, politicians at the farthest ends of the political spectrum have learned how to talk around the topic of race even as they engage in identity politics.Marine Le Pen, who took over her fatherâs party, has called France the âleast racistâ country on the planet, campaigning as a law-and-order candidate who aims to unify the nation.
Her campaignâs flagship proposal, meanwhile, is a referendum that would amend the constitution to create a two-tier legal system granting different rights to citizens and noncitizens, a clear departure from universalism.MĂ©lenchon, meanwhile, has capitalized on support among French Muslims following his refusal to condemn Hamas as a terrorist organization and attend an antisemitism march in the wake of the Oct. 7, 2023 attacks on Israel.
He won 62% of the French Muslim vote in the 2024 European elections according to exit polling.His presidential platform calls for the creation of a âNouvelle Franceâ that represents the âheirs of immigration.â Rather than openly embrace American-style multiculturalism, MĂ©lenchon talks of the âcreolizationâ of French society, a concept that recognizes cultural differences without treating them as fixed identities.In the wake of the recent riots, MĂ©lenchon has played a lead role in policing the speech of presidential candidates in the dwindling center.Former Prime Minister Ădouard Philippe, the political establishmentâs leading presidential candidate, was recently asked to characterize the looters.âThere were, in fact, a certain numberâa significant number, probablyâof young French people who I consider French from an immigrant background,â he said. For Philippe, the riots were a sign the French model was failing in its mission of cultural integration.âWe have to look in the mirror and ask how do we build a nation?
How do we make it for those who arrived one, two or three generations ago?âMĂ©lenchon swiftly wrote on X that Philippe was âdividing the countryâ with âracialistâ rhetoric.Just days after the mid-October riots, France was confronted with the very ethnic violence it feared identity politics might produce. A gunman authorities identified as âKevin T.â went on a shooting spree in a banlieue of Paris, killing a man of African descent and wounding seven others, including a 12-year-old girl wearing a headscarf who was shot multiple times.The banlieue he targeted, Trappes, is celebrated for producing some of the countryâs most famous actors of African descent.
The shooter later told police he went there looking for âMuslim, African, North African types.â When police raided his residence they found a copy of Mein Kampf and stickers that read â100% French,â which the shooter said he had designed himself.âThis is a turning point,â Macron told reporters as he visited Trappes in the aftermath, warning the public to ânot fall into the trap of one camp against another.âWrite to Stacy Meichtry at Stacy.Meichtry@wsj.com and Bertrand Benoit at bertrand.benoit@wsj.com

