The Supreme Court on Tuesday asked journalist Nikhil Wagle and Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut to file additional affidavits placing their explanations and apologies on record in a criminal contempt case over their remarks targeting Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and the judiciary.A bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi was hearing the matter initiated on a petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA).During the hearing, senior advocate Kirti Uppal, appearing for Raut, urged the court not to insist on his repeated physical presence, citing his medical condition. Uppal told the bench that Raut is a cancer patient undergoing chemotherapy and also has heart-related ailments.Senior advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for Wagle, also sought consideration of her age and said she was unable to come to court because of pollution.
JUDGES ASK FOR ADDITIONAL AFFIDAVITSDuring the proceedings, Jaising spoke about the role of journalists, describing journalism as a "hugely honourable profession". She said she regretted never having become a full-time journalist, adding that journalists play an important role in communicating the law to the public.Responding to her remarks, the bench made a light-hearted observation, saying, "That's okay...you control the journalists." Justice Kumar acknowledged Jaising's dedication to the legal profession, saying that once a person enters a profession, they must remain committed to it.
He added that she was someone the Bar could emulate. However, the judge asked her to ensure that her client responded to the court's directions and filed another affidavit.Jaising submitted that the particular word used by Wagle had unfortunately entered common parlance but was not appropriate, especially when used in reference to the Supreme Court.
She said her client had appeared before the court and tendered an apology.The bench, however, insisted that the apology and any other explanation be formally placed on record."Whatever he wants to say, whether by apology or otherwise, you put it on affidavit," Justice Kumar said, directing the filing of an additional affidavit.WHY ARE WAGLE AND RAUT FACING CONTEMPT PROCEEDINGS?The contempt case stems from remarks made by Wagle and Raut concerning CJI Surya Kant and the judiciary after the Chief Justice declined to meet a delegation of Opposition leaders seeking to raise concerns over the Election Commission and protests in Delhi.Wagle allegedly posted an abusive remark targeting the CJI on X. He subsequently deleted the post and tendered an unconditional apology.Raut, meanwhile, made allegations that judges attended political programmes organised by the ruling party and accepted hospitality from Chief Ministers.
He also made references to alleged interactions between judges and political leaders.The SCBA approached Attorney General R Venkataramani seeking consent to initiate criminal contempt proceedings against the two. The Attorney General granted consent on October 15, observing that the remarks were prima facie scandalous and intended to lower the esteem of the Supreme Court, particularly the office of the CJI.On October 16, the Supreme Court issued show-cause notices to Wagle and Raut, asking why criminal contempt proceedings should not be initiated against them.At a subsequent hearing on October 28, the court permitted Wagle to appear virtually at the next hearing after his counsel informed the bench that he had tendered an unconditional apology.
Raut was directed to appear physically before the court on November 17.The latest directions seek to ensure that the explanations and apologies of both respondents are formally placed before the court through additional affidavits.- Ends

