Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's remarks on India's relationship with Israel and its position on the Gaza conflict have triggered criticism from sections of his own perceived support base, with Congress backers, progressive voices, and long-time party supporters questioning his position.While senior Congress leaders hailed their leader's comments as a "statesmanlike articulation" of India's foreign policy, some of his supporters said his emphasis on maintaining strategic ties with Israel fell short of the moral clarity they expected from him.The Leader of Opposition (LoP) in the Lok Sabha was interacting with students at the University of Chicago on Wednesday (November 18) when he was asked about India's relationship with Israel and its implications for the country's role in global geopolitics.Rahul said India should maintain strong relations with Israel, including defence cooperation, but stressed that strategic interests should not prevent New Delhi from speaking out against Israel's actions in Gaza. "We have good relations with Israel, and we buy weapons from them. But we are a much bigger country, with a population of 1.5 billion, and our foreign policy should be based on what is good for us, not on what is good for someone else," he said in Chicago.The LoP condemned the October 7 terrorist attacks on Israel and the killing of innocent people, but also criticised Israel's actions in Gaza. "I condemn what happened in October and that was absolutely horrible.
But I also condemn what Israel has done in Gaza," Rahul said, adding that one wrong could not justify another.He also argued that India needed to demonstrate its influence on the global stage without being constrained by any country, including Israel, the United States, Russia or China.The Congress has historically supported Palestinian self-determination while gradually building diplomatic and strategic ties with Israel. The party had opposed the 1947 UN partition plan and backed Palestinian aspirations, with India recognising the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) in 1974 and the State of Palestine in 1988.However, under former PM PV Narasimha Rao, India established full diplomatic relations with Israel in 1992, while continuing to support a two-state solution and Palestinian rights.MY POLITICAL SUPPORT DOES NOT MEAN SURRENDERING PRINCIPLES: RAHUL SUPPORTERArshiya, a user on X, who has previously expressed admiration for Rahul Gandhi and described him as the leader India needs, questioned his position on maintaining ties with Israel."There is simply no comparison between October 7 (which was horrific) and what Israel has inflicted upon Gaza.
Israel is a genocidal apartheid state. Neutrality in the face of genocide is complicity," she wrote.Making it clear that her criticism did not mean withdrawing her political support for Gandhi, she added, "As much as I admire Rahul Gandhi and want him to succeed, my political support does not come with a surrender of my principles."She also said that no politician should be above criticism, particularly when it comes to matters of conscience.Academic and writer Apoorvanand, who has frequently criticised the BJP and Hindutva politics and has previously expressed support for Rahul as an opposition leader, was also critical of the remarks."When the civilised world is asking for sanctions against Israel to force it to end the genocide and apartheid, this statement from Rahul Gandhi is deeply disappointing and disturbing," he wrote on X."You cannot fight against genocidal politics domestically and be friends with it outside," he added.Journalist Pranav Pradhi, who has previously praised Gandhi as a key figure in the Opposition's fight against the BJP, also expressed disappointment."Sorry, but this is the worst statement I have seen from Rahul Gandhi," he wrote.Pradhi argued that many people viewed Gandhi as a different kind of politician because they expected him to take positions beyond conventional political calculations."But then he comes out with a statement that sounds no different from what we hear from any other politician," he said, adding that Gandhi's response was disappointing because it appeared to place strategic calculations above the moral position many supporters expected him to take.Mohd Shadab Khan, an X user, alleged that the Congress-led government in Telangana under Chief Minister Revanth Reddy's leadership are arresting Muslim youth."In Telangana, Revanth Reddy's government is arresting Muslim youths over their pro-Palestine, anti-Israel stance," he wrote on X."Meanwhile, Rahul Gandhi is sitting in America, singing praises of terrorist state Netanyahu's Israel.
And that Minority Department? Still polishing its favourite slogan? "Yeh jawani hai qurbaan, Rahul Gandhi tere naam," he added.LONG-TIME CONGRESS SUPPORTERS QUESTION PARTY'S SECULAR IDEALSThe criticism also came from people who explicitly identified themselves as long-time Congress supporters.An X user with the handle Hussain Jakeer said Rahul's position had left him disappointed, questioning how the Congress leader could speak about secularism, love and empathy while maintaining good relations with Israel."I have been a Congress supporter all these years because of its secular ideals.
RG's statement is very disappointing. He talks about love, empathy and secularism but he can't call Israel's genocide in Gaza," he wrote.He also argued that Rahul's position made him no different from the BJP government's approach towards Palestine.Another user, writing under the handle @bekhayalime, questioned the contrast between Rahul's remarks and the positions taken by his mother, Sonia Gandhi, and sister, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra.The user said it was disappointing that Rahul had advocated maintaining friendly relations with Israel while Sonia and Priyanka had publicly criticised Israel's actions in Gaza.CONGRESS LEADERS BACK RAHUL GANDHI'S ISRAEL STANCERahul's remarks received support from senior Congress leaders, who defended his emphasis on India's strategic interests and independent foreign policy.Supriya Shrinate, chairperson of the Congress's Social Media and Digital Platforms department, called it a "statesmanly response", saying Gandhi had called out hypocrisy and placed India's interests above those of other countries."We have strategic reasons for a relationship with Israel.
We buy weapons from them. Frankly, we need to buy the best weapons and they happen to produce very good weapons," she wrote on X, quoting Rahul's remarks.Congress national spokesperson Shama Mohamed also praised Rahul, saying he had spoken like a true leader by condemning Israel's actions in Gaza and reminding the Narendra Modi government that India's foreign policy should be guided by its own interests."PM Modi must learn from our leader how to take a stand.
Well done, Rahul Ji!" she wrote.However, the response from some Congress supporters and people who have previously expressed admiration for Rahul Gandhi gained spotlight.- Ends

