Key events13m agoDeep divides as second week of talks beginDeep divides as second week of talks beginFiona HarveyIt is a measure of how difficult a battle the Australian presidency of negotiations and the Turkish hosts of the conference face at Cop31 that, as the second week of talks begins, there are still deep divides not only as to what the outcome of this Cop should be, but even over what form it should take.Deep into Saturday night, ahead of the official rest day on Sunday, negotiators from around the world were still slugging it out over whether this Cop should have a “cover decision”.As regular readers of this blog will know, cover decisions are a standard feature of Cops, and have been for more than two decades. They function as a useful negotiating device to capture progress made in the talks that does not fall neatly into the other negotiating strands, such as those on the mitigation work programme (on reductions in greenhouse gas emissions) or on finance.This has rarely been controversial – cover decisions have included a wide variety of issues that are important without fitting neatly within the other “work programmes”, and have included the state of the oceans, the impact of the climate crisis on food security and health, new science, and clarifications of the outcome of Cop discussions.One long time Cop participant told the Guardian: “Optimally all items would find a space in the negotiated decisions.
If that is not possible, then there has to be enough political goodwill and diplomacy to carry off an ambitious cover decision.”But after Cop28 in 2023 in Dubai produced a cover decision whose 28th paragraph included the key pledge to “transition away from fossil fuels”, some countries took a harder line. At Cop29 in Baku, the Azerbaijani hosts complied with the wishes of regional allies and announced there would be no cover decision.
This stifled further discussion of the “transition away from fossil fuels”, as it could not be incorporated easily into other negotiating strands.The following year, in Belem, the Brazilian hosts reinstated a cover decision, which allowed for a reference to the Dubai decision (the “UAE consensus”) to be included.This year, the best way to take forward issues including Brazil’s global roadmap on the transition away from fossil fuels, the global electrification target, and the controversy over whether the work of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change should be delayed, would be a cover decision.But the Arab Group, Russia, and the Like-Minded Developing Countries (a loose grouping that sometimes includes China and India, but also Saudi Arabia and allies among fossil fuel producers such as Bolivia and Venezuela) are opposed to having any form of cover decision at this year’s Cop. They are claiming there is no legal basis within the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change for having a cover decision, which is an odd stance for countries that have signed up to so many of them over the years.The row is likely to continue, and could hold up progress in the talks.
It is seen by some as a sign of how the absence of the US has affected the talks, as under Joe Biden and Barack Obama, US negotiating teams were known to some as the “Saudi whisperers”.With the world leaders gone, the negotiations will now hinge on whether countries can find common ground. Simon Stiell, executive secretary of the UNFCCC, called for flexibility in their positions: “There is no collective success without compromise from every party.”

