Madras High Court judge Justice GR Swaminathan on Monday slammed CPI(M) leader and Madurai Lok Sabha MP Su Venkatesan for commenting on his judicial responsibilities. During an open-court hearing, the judge also referred to the MP travelling in a Mercedes-Benz car and wearing branded clothes and shoes.The remarks came during the hearing of a contempt petition concerning alleged irregularities in the purchase of books for public libraries across Tamil Nadu.

The exchange followed Venkatesan's criticism of Justice Swaminathan's comments at a recent book launch about the alleged fraudulent procurement of books for the Periyar Arivulagam Library in Coimbatore.At the book launch, Justice Swaminathan had suggested in a lighter vein that books on spirituality concerning the late Kanchi Shankaracharya could be placed on shelves left vacant after the disputed books were withdrawn. He described the suggestion as an act of atonement for the alleged wrongdoing.Responding on Sunday, Venkatesan said fraud in library book procurement was an act of corruption and should be punished under the law.

He said imposing punishment for corruption was the responsibility of a judge, while prescribing atonement for sins was the work of astrologers. During Monday's contempt hearing, Justice Swaminathan clarified that his suggestion about placing spiritual books in the library had been made only as a joke.He then responded to Venkatesan's remarks and recalled meeting the MP by chance at Chennai railway station about six months earlier, before they boarded the Pandian Express to Madurai.

The judge said Venkatesan had arrived at the station in a high-end Mercedes-Benz and was dressed in branded clothes and shoes. He said the MP's appearance had initially led him to believe that Venkatesan was a corporate executive.Justice Swaminathan remarked that Venkatesan identified himself as a communist leader but travelled in a luxury car and used branded products.

He also wondered whether royalties from books could support such a lifestyle.Recalling their brief conversation as they walked towards the train, the judge said Venkatesan was travelling in First AC, while he usually travelled in Sleeper Class. According to Justice Swaminathan, the MP asked him where he was going, to which he replied that he normally travelled in Sleeper Class and that his berth was S3-23.Justice Swaminathan concluded his response by objecting to Venkatesan telling him how he should perform his duties as a judge.However, the war of words showed no signs of abating, with Su Venkatesan hitting back at Justice Swaminathan over his remarks about the MP's alleged use of a luxury car and branded clothes.

Taking to X, the CPI(M) leader said he had never owned a car and that the Mercedes-Benz he arrived in at the railway station did not belong to him.Defending his travel in First AC, Venkatesan said his train journeys were covered by the travel entitlement granted to MPs. He argued that travelling in First AC did not make a person's views wrong, just as travelling in Sleeper Class did not make their words right.Taking pride in his communist ideology, Venkatesan said people should be judged by their views and actions rather than their clothes, cars or travel class.

He also accused his critics of making a personal attack based on superficial observations without checking the facts.- Ends