We The Leaders chief K Annamalai on Friday termed the controversy over lighting the traditional Karthigai Deepam lamp at Thiruparankundram hill a "manufactured controversy", accusing the Joseph Vijay-led government of following the same approach adopted by the previous DMK government and urging it to implement the Supreme Court's directions without seeking a review.Speaking exclusively to India Today TV, the former BJP chief said there was no controversy on the ground and that both Hindu and Muslim communities in the area had no objection to the proposed lamp-lighting ceremony. He said he had visited Madurai and was near Thiruparankundram on Friday evening, where he found the situation peaceful."It is a manufactured controversy.
I don't think there is any controversy at all. I just came from Madurai.
I was near Thiruparankundram today evening. It is absolutely peaceful, and both the community people, be it the Hindu, be it the Muslim community, nobody has got any problem," he said.His remarks came shortly after the Supreme Court permitted the lighting of the traditional Karthigai Deepam lamp on November 24, as a one-time temporary measure at Deepathoon, a stone pillar atop Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai.
Describing the controversy as entirely political, Annamalai maintained that the situation on the ground remained harmonious and called on the administration to implement the courtâs directions "to the T". "Just follow the Supreme Court judgement that was given today, be it an interim judgement, to the T. They have clearly said a group of people led by the government, a committee has to go up, light the lamp, and come down.
They have to do it," he said.Tracing the long-standing demand by devotees of Lord Muruga to light the lamp at Deepathoon, Annamalai pointed out that the Madras High Court had already settled the issue last year. He noted that both a single-judge bench and a division bench had passed orders permitting the ritual, that the stateâs appeals had failed, and that the Supreme Court had never stayed those rulings.
Accusing the TVK administration of repeating the tactics of the previous DMK regime, Annamalai said the earlier government had prolonged the matter during an election year."Very unfortunately, the current TVK government is also playing the same game that the DMK played last year when they were in government," he said, adding that attempts were made to dismiss the pillar as a "British-era survey stone."Annamalai also contended that members of the Muslim community had not instigated the dispute, blaming the state machinery for escalating it legally. "Last year too, the Muslim fringe never created an issue. After the judgement came, it was the Tamil Nadu government that made the Jamath go on appeal, which is again unfortunate," he said.Urging the ruling dispensation and its allies not to file a review petition, Annamalai stressed that both the administration and the petitioners must respect the apex court's conditions, including restrictions on movement and slogan-raising."Just follow the Supreme Court judgement given today, even if it is an interim judgement, to the T.
They have clearly said a committee has to go up, light the lamp, and come down. On the sacred day, you light the lamp and the problem is solved," he said, questioning why the government was diverting its attention to what he termed a "non-issue" instead of focusing on pressing governance matters.Earlier on Friday, a Supreme Court bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi stayed portions of the earlier judgment upholding the restoration of the lamp-lighting practice at Deepathoon, while moulding interim relief for this year's festival."We deem it appropriate to mould the interim relief in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case.
Hence, we consider it appropriate to permit the lighting of the ceremonial lamp on 24.11.2026 at the stone pillar identified as Deepathoon, through a restricted team authorised by the Devasthanam," the bench ordered.The court clarified that the permission was strictly a temporary arrangement and did not recognise or enforce any customary, religious, or proprietary right, nor could it be cited as a precedent in future years."The limited accommodation made today is not a determination of the dispute; it is an arrangement made precisely because the dispute remains to be determined," the justices observed, leaving open all questions of title, possession, customary usage, and access while posting the matter for hearing in the second week of January next year.Under the courtâs strict safeguards, only a restricted team authorised by the temple administration and necessary officials may access the pillar. The District Collector of Madurai will act as the nodal officer to finalise the teamâs size, timing, route, and safety measures in consultation with the Temple Executive Officer, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), and the Madurai Commissioner of Police, while the Union government has been directed to examine deploying a Central Reserve Police Force contingent if required.The dispute at the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy temple centres on competing claims between Hindu worshippers and the Hazrat Sultan Sikandar Badusha Auliya dargah over ownership of the hilltop and the location of the ritual.
While the deepam has for decades been lit at the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar temple on the lower slopes, Hindu groups sought to perform the ritual at Deepathoon, roughly 50 metres from the dargah. On Thursday, the dargah side told the apex court that it owns the entire hilltop and opposed the demand.- Ends

